Alternatives
Four ways to get web data, compared plainly.
Most teams choose between a scraper subscription, a scraper marketplace, a single provider’s API or a unified API like PrimaryAPI. Each is the right call for someone. Here is how they differ, including where we are not the best fit.
When a source breaks
who fixes it
- Scraper subscriptionsYou switch providers yourself
- Scraper marketplacesYou switch scrapers yourself
- Single-provider APIsYou add a second vendor yourself
- PrimaryAPIThe next healthy provider answers, inside the same call
The options
Four approaches, four trade-offs
None of these is wrong. They put the work, the risk and the bill in different places.
Scraper subscriptions
A monthly plan with a quota of requests or credits from one scraping provider. You send URLs or queries; it handles proxies and browsers.
- Pricing
- Monthly tiers with a request or credit quota.
- Good fit when
- Steady, high volume against a few sites, and a team that wants raw pages and full control of parsing.
- Watch for
- Paying for quota you do not use. Parsing and schema changes stay with you, and one provider’s bad day is yours too.
Scraper marketplaces
Community-built scrapers that you run on someone else’s infrastructure, paying for compute time or per result.
- Pricing
- Per run, per compute unit or per result, set scraper by scraper.
- Good fit when
- Niche or long-tail sites where someone has already built a scraper, and you are happy to pick and tune it yourself.
- Watch for
- Every scraper has its own inputs and output shape, and upkeep depends on its author. Retries and switching are on you.
Single-provider APIs
One vendor’s API for one kind of data: a search results API, an email verification service, or a platform’s official API.
- Pricing
- Per call or monthly plans, set by each vendor.
- Good fit when
- One data type at scale, a direct contract or SLA, or official access to a platform.
- Watch for
- A separate key, bill and response shape for every provider you add, and no fallback when that provider fails.
Unified data APIs
One key and one balance in front of many data APIs from many providers. PrimaryAPI is one of these.
- Pricing
- Per call from a prepaid balance, or credits within a monthly plan, depending on the product.
- Good fit when
- Many kinds of data, uneven volume, and AI agents that need to find and pay for data on their own.
- Watch for
- A layer between you and the source, with its own margin. Niche sources may not be covered yet; ask how failures and misses are billed.
Side by side
The criteria that change your bill
Typical behaviour for each approach, next to the facts for our own product. Individual products vary, so check the ones you are considering.
| Scraper subscriptions | Scraper marketplaces | Single-provider APIs | Unified data APIs | PrimaryAPI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Monthly plan with a quota | Per run, compute or result | Set by each vendor | Prepaid balance or plan credits | Credits, charged per call. Pay as you go has no monthly fee or minimum; plans include credits every month. |
| What a failed call costs | Depends on the plan | Depends on the scraper | Depends on the vendor | Varies; ask before you commit | Nothing when every provider fails, or when we refuse the call before routing. |
| When a source breaks | You switch providers yourself | You switch scrapers yourself | You add a second vendor yourself | Some route around it, some leave it to you | Automatic failover to the next cheapest healthy provider, inside the same call. |
| Response shape | Raw pages or provider-specific JSON | Different for each scraper | Different for each vendor | Normalised or per provider, by product | One input and output schema per API, whichever provider answers. |
| Agent support | Varies by provider | Varies; some offer MCP | Varies by vendor | Often MCP; sign-up flows vary | Keyless discovery over MCP, SKILL.md, and self-signup with capped trial keys a person approves. |
| Coverage | Any site you can parse | Broad, quality varies | One kind of data | Many kinds of data; depth varies | 200 APIs across 31 platforms today, added as each passes our checks. |
Pricing model
- Scraper subscriptions
- Monthly plan with a quota
- Scraper marketplaces
- Per run, compute or result
- Single-provider APIs
- Set by each vendor
- Unified data APIs
- Prepaid balance or plan credits
- PrimaryAPI
- Credits, charged per call. Pay as you go has no monthly fee or minimum; plans include credits every month.
What a failed call costs
- Scraper subscriptions
- Depends on the plan
- Scraper marketplaces
- Depends on the scraper
- Single-provider APIs
- Depends on the vendor
- Unified data APIs
- Varies; ask before you commit
- PrimaryAPI
- Nothing when every provider fails, or when we refuse the call before routing.
When a source breaks
- Scraper subscriptions
- You switch providers yourself
- Scraper marketplaces
- You switch scrapers yourself
- Single-provider APIs
- You add a second vendor yourself
- Unified data APIs
- Some route around it, some leave it to you
- PrimaryAPI
- Automatic failover to the next cheapest healthy provider, inside the same call.
Response shape
- Scraper subscriptions
- Raw pages or provider-specific JSON
- Scraper marketplaces
- Different for each scraper
- Single-provider APIs
- Different for each vendor
- Unified data APIs
- Normalised or per provider, by product
- PrimaryAPI
- One input and output schema per API, whichever provider answers.
Agent support
- Scraper subscriptions
- Varies by provider
- Scraper marketplaces
- Varies; some offer MCP
- Single-provider APIs
- Varies by vendor
- Unified data APIs
- Often MCP; sign-up flows vary
- PrimaryAPI
- Keyless discovery over MCP, SKILL.md, and self-signup with capped trial keys a person approves.
Coverage
- Scraper subscriptions
- Any site you can parse
- Scraper marketplaces
- Broad, quality varies
- Single-provider APIs
- One kind of data
- Unified data APIs
- Many kinds of data; depth varies
- PrimaryAPI
- 200 APIs across 31 platforms today, added as each passes our checks.
The first four columns describe approaches, not specific products. The PrimaryAPI column describes this product as of October 30, 2026.
Honest limits
When we are not the right choice
Better you hear it here than after you have integrated.
You need data behind a login
We serve public, logged-out data and licensed providers only. We never use anyone’s account, password or cookies.
You need a contractual uptime guarantee
We publish measured uptime from our request log, but we do not offer a service-level agreement today.
You make one kind of call at very high, steady volume
A direct contract with a single provider may cost less once your volume is large and predictable.
You need to make decisions about people
Credit, employment, housing and insurance decisions need a consumer reporting agency. We are not one, and our terms forbid that use.
We don’t have the data yet
Ask for it. Until it ships, a marketplace scraper or the source’s own API may get you there sooner.
Checklist
Eight questions to ask any data provider
Including us. The answers decide what you actually pay and what happens on a bad day.
What does a failed call cost? And a “not found”?
Our answer: Failed everywhere: nothing. Not found: free unless the API page says misses are billed.
Can I see what a call costs before I make it?
Our answer: Yes: every API page lists its price in credits, a free quote gives the price for your exact input, and the pricing page says what a credit costs on each plan.
Is there a subscription, a minimum or an expiry on what I prepay?
Our answer: Pay as you go has no monthly fee or minimum, and plans are optional. Bought credits never expire; credits included with a plan roll over for 3 months.
What happens when the upstream source breaks?
Our answer: The next cheapest healthy provider answers inside the same call.
Can I cap spend per key, per agent and per call?
Our answer: Yes: spend limits per key, trial caps for agents and maxCredits per call.
Do they publish measured uptime, and how it is computed?
Our answer: The network page shows figures from our request log and explains the method.
Where does the data come from?
Our answer: Public, logged-out sources and licensed providers. Each API page shows its live health.
How long are my inputs and results kept?
Our answer: Full results for 24 hours by default. Restricted-API inputs only as a hash.
Product comparisons
PrimaryAPI next to specific products
Each comparison uses facts read from the other product’s public pages on October 30, 2026, and says where it is the better choice.
- PrimaryAPI vs 1LookupA subscription with one credit balance across validation, enrichment, social and intelligence products. How its plans, caching and bulk tools compare with per-call credits, no monthly fee on Pay as you go, and failover.Subscription data APIFacts as of October 30, 2026
- PrimaryAPI vs MonidA prepaid balance in front of thousands of individual provider endpoints, each with its provider’s own schema. How that compares with one schema per job and automatic failover.Agent tool marketplaceFacts as of October 30, 2026
- PrimaryAPI vs ComposioManaged logins and tool execution so agents can act inside people’s own apps, plus pay-per-call Instant tools. A different job from public data, and how the two fit together.Agent integration platformFacts as of October 30, 2026
Product and company names on these pages are trademarks of their respective owners. Mentioning them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we will correct it.
Judge it on a real call.
Welcome credits are enough to try several APIs. If we are not the right fit, you have lost nothing but a few minutes.